When ambitious reporter Allie Rusch is recruited by music manager Vivian Cartwright to play cupid to famous pop artists Caleb Greene and Carson Peet in exchange Allie soon realizes Caleb has his sights. Torn between her career move and her growing feelings for Caleb, Allie is left to wonder whether Caleb can be coerced by her into some thing if she should fall in love and then make him her own Valentine, or his heart doesn't desire.